What Are the Downsides of Smart Meters in the UK?
What are the downsides of smart meters in the UK? The honest answer is that the meter itself is a good idea with a patchy record. Around 3 million smart meters are not working as smart meters at all, a third of owners still have to submit manual readings, and the small screen on the kitchen worktop is the part most likely to break. A smart meter does not save you money on its own, it records your electricity use every half hour unless you ask it not to, and it gives your supplier a remote switch that can move you onto prepayment. None of that makes smart meters a bad idea for everyone, but it does mean the decision deserves more than the letter from your supplier suggests. This guide works through every real downside, with the latest official figures and the 2026 rules that protect you if yours goes wrong.
The scale of the rollout is worth knowing first, because it frames everything else. At the end of June 2026 there were 42 million smart and advanced meters in homes and small businesses across Great Britain, about 72 percent of all meters, according to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. Of the roughly 40 million smart meters, 92 percent were operating in smart mode, which means they were communicating with the supplier as designed. That leaves 3,133,000 smart meters operating in traditional mode, in other words working exactly like the old meter they replaced. Between April and June 2026 suppliers installed 1.1 million smart and advanced meters, but only 525,000 of those were new installations. The other 570,000 were replacements for existing smart meters, which tells you something about how often the hardware needs swapping.
The short answer: what are the downsides of smart meters in the UK?
What are the downsides of smart meters in the UK? The biggest is that yours may not work as a smart meter. About 3 million smart meters in Great Britain are stuck in traditional mode, so they record your usage accurately but never send a reading, and you are back to estimated bills and manual readings. The second is the in-home display, the small screen that shows what you are spending. It is the part owners report breaking most often, and after a year your supplier can charge you 30 to 50 pounds for a replacement. The third is that a smart meter does not cut your bill by itself. It only helps if you change what you do because of what it shows you. Then there are the quieter concerns: half-hourly data about your home, the remote switch to prepayment, friction with solar panels, and a second round of replacements as mobile networks switch off 2G and 3G. The rest of this guide takes each one in turn, with the numbers behind it and what you can do about it.
How a smart meter is supposed to work
A smart meter is a gas or electricity meter that sends readings to your supplier automatically, over a secure national network run by the Data Communications Company. The electricity meter talks to the network through a communications hub, and the gas meter talks to the hub, which then passes both sets of readings on. You also get an in-home display, a small screen that shows your energy use in near real time and what it is costing you. The point of the whole system is accurate bills without manual readings, plus the half-hourly data that makes cheaper off-peak tariffs possible. When it works, that is what you get. The downsides below are what happens when any part of that chain fails, and how often it does.
Downside 1: around 3 million smart meters are not working as smart meters
This is the single biggest downside, and it is not a rare edge case. The government’s own June 2026 figures show 3,133,000 smart meters operating in traditional mode. They still measure your gas and electricity correctly, but they do not communicate, so your supplier gets no automatic readings and your bills go back to estimates until you submit readings yourself. Citizens Advice puts the human cost plainly: over a third of people with smart meters, 6.7 million households, regularly have to submit manual readings, a 20 percent increase on last year. Worse, 1.2 million households have not been receiving accurate bills as expected since having their meter installed. In 2026 so far, the most common reason for people complaining to their energy supplier was a problem with their smart meter, according to the Energy Consumer Satisfaction Survey jointly commissioned by Ofgem and Citizens Advice.
Why do they stop communicating? The Data Communications Company lists the usual causes: no smart meter network coverage where you live, software on the meter that needs updating, a switch to a supplier that has not yet connected to your meter, a first-generation meter that was never upgraded, or the physical location of the meter itself. Thick walls, basements and distance between the gas meter and the electricity meter’s communications hub can all break the link. If your bills are marked as estimated rather than smart, or your supplier keeps asking you to read the meter, yours is probably one of the three million. The fix is your supplier’s responsibility, and since March 2026 there is a deadline on it, which we cover below.
Downside 2: first-generation meters can go dumb when you switch supplier
If your smart meter was installed in the early years of the rollout, it may be a first-generation SMETS1 meter. These were installed from around 2013, before the national network existed, and each one was tied to the system of the supplier that fitted it. Switch to a different supplier and the new company often could not talk to your meter at all, so it lost its smart functions and you were back to manual readings. Which? heard exactly this from its members: one E.ON Next customer reported that their smart meters stopped being smart about two months after switching, and were eventually replaced.
The industry has spent years fixing this. A national migration programme moves SMETS1 meters onto the Data Communications Company network with a remote firmware update, and around 11 million had been migrated by June 2026. Smart DCC reported 10,353,640 SMETS1 meters operating on its systems on 31 October 2026. Most early meters have now regained their smart functions and should keep them when you switch again. But not every SMETS1 meter can be migrated, and if yours cannot, it will need to be replaced. Citizens Advice has an online checker that tells you whether your meter should work in smart mode after switching, which is worth using before you change supplier. If you are about to switch and your meter is an early model, check first rather than discovering the problem two months later.
Downside 3: the in-home display is the part that breaks most
The in-home display is the small screen your supplier hands you at installation, and it is the part of the system you actually interact with. It is also the part owners report breaking most often. In a Which? survey of 813 members with smart meters in August 2026, 31 percent said they had a problem with their smart meter in the past 12 months, and the display was the most common complaint. The faults people report are familiar: the screen loses connection with the meter, shows data for electricity but not gas, shows a blank screen, or shows incorrect figures. One Octopus Energy customer told Which? they felt abandoned without the advantage they had been promised, a display that shows current consumption so you can see the effect in real time of turning appliances on or off.
There are simple fixes worth trying first. Move the display closer to your meters, since it works best nearby. Check it is plugged in, because unplugged displays do not hold charge for long. Turn it off and on again. If none of that works, contact your supplier, which should investigate before considering a replacement. Under Ofgem rules, if your display is less than 12 months old and faulty, your supplier should fix or replace it free of charge. After 12 months, your supplier does not have to repair it and can charge you for a new one, typically 30 to 50 pounds. Eleven suppliers, including the biggest six, have signed up to voluntary government principles that commit them to troubleshooting display problems properly and offering a replacement or a next-best solution such as the same functions in an app. If your supplier is not one of them, the app on your phone is the fallback, though most supplier apps show your usage with a lag of about a day.
Downside 4: a smart meter does not save you money on its own
This is the misunderstanding at the heart of the whole rollout. A smart meter measures your energy use. It does not reduce it. Citizens Advice puts it simply: a smart meter will not automatically save you money. You save when you change something because of what it shows you, such as turning the heating down after seeing what it costs, or moving the laundry to a cheaper time of day. The government said households with smart meters saved an estimated 700 million pounds on their bills in 2025, but that is the government’s own estimate of the savings from behaviour change across millions of homes, not money the meter puts in your pocket by itself.
Where a smart meter can genuinely save you money is tariffs. Many of the cheapest deals now need a smart meter to work, because they charge different prices at different times of day and the meter supplies the half-hourly readings that make that possible. If you are on a standard variable tariff and never change your habits, a smart meter changes nothing about your bill except its accuracy. That is still worth something, since accurate bills end the cycle of estimated bills and catch-up charges, but it is not a saving. If you want the meter to pay, pair it with the habits that actually cut usage. Turning the thermostat down by one degree is the single biggest free change, and our guide to what temperature to set your thermostat in winter explains the number the Energy Saving Trust recommends room by room. For the full stack of cheap fixes, see our guide to the best ways to save on your electric bill during the winter.
Downside 5: your energy use is recorded every half hour
By default, your electricity meter sends a reading every half hour and your gas meter sends one once a month. That is far more detailed than the old system of one reading every few months, and it is the part of smart meters that worries people most. The detail is real: half-hourly readings can show when you get up, when you cook, when you go on holiday. But the controls are also real, and stronger than most people realise. You can ask your supplier to take daily readings or monthly readings instead of half-hourly ones. Only your supplier, or a third party you have explicitly permitted, can see how much energy you use and when. The Data Communications Company, which runs the network, transports the readings securely to your supplier and does not store your consumption data. The meter itself holds no name, address or bank details, only how much energy you have used and what tariff you are on.
There are two honest caveats. First, the default is half-hourly, and many people never change it, because nobody tells them they can. If the detail bothers you, change it in your online account or by calling your supplier. Monthly is the minimum your supplier needs to bill you accurately. Second, the richer picture of your home does not come from the meter itself. It comes from the devices you add yourself, such as home energy monitors and smart plugs, which are covered by their own privacy terms. The meter is the least of your data worries in a connected home, but the choice about reading frequency should be yours, and it is.
Downside 6: your supplier can switch you to prepayment remotely
A traditional prepayment meter has to be fitted by an engineer visiting your home. A smart meter can be switched to prepayment mode remotely, with no visit at all. That is a genuine downside, because it removes the practical friction that used to slow the process down, and it is the feature that caused the most anger when suppliers were found forcing vulnerable households onto prepayment in 2023. The rules are the same whether your meter is smart or traditional. Pay-as-you-go for debt collection should only be a last resort. Before switching you, your supplier must check that prepayment is safe, practical and easy for you to access, and that you are not in a vulnerable situation. You should get at least seven working days’ notice if your smart meter is going to change to prepayment, and the meter can also be switched back to credit mode remotely.
In practice, the protection depends on your supplier following those rules, and the 2023 scandal showed that some did not. If you are in debt, the safer route is to contact your supplier before it contacts you, agree a repayment plan, and ask about the extra help available for vulnerable customers. If you think your supplier has moved you to prepayment unfairly, complain to the supplier first, and if the issue is not resolved after eight weeks, take it to the Energy Ombudsman. The remote switch is a real risk, but it is also a risk with a defined complaint route, which is more than can be said for some of the other downsides on this list.
Downside 7: solar panels and smart meters do not always get along
If you have solar panels, a smart meter should be your friend. All SMETS meters can measure energy moving in both directions, what you import from the grid and what you export back to it, and a smart meter is generally what you need to sign up for a Smart Export Guarantee tariff that pays you for exported electricity, because those tariffs need half-hourly readings. In practice, Which? hears regularly from solar owners whose smart meters and panels are not working well together. The most common complaint is that the in-home display shows consumption only, not generation, so it cannot tell you how much electricity your panels are producing. Your panels usually have their own generation meter for that, and many supplier and third-party apps can show generation alongside use, but the display on the worktop cannot.
There are also cases where the meter does not measure exported electricity correctly, which directly affects what you are paid. If that happens to you, contact your supplier and ask it to investigate. And if you have solar panels but no smart meter yet, tell your supplier before installation and check whether the meter and display will work fully with your panels. A badly planned installation can leave you with a meter that records your imports perfectly and your exports not at all, which is the worst of both worlds.
Downside 8: signal, flats and thick walls
A smart meter is only as good as its connection, and the connection has to cross two gaps. The first is the wide area network between your home and the Data Communications Company. The second is the home area network between your gas meter and the electricity meter’s communications hub. The wide area network now covers over 99 percent of homes and small businesses in Great Britain, according to the DCC, so most homes are fine. But the second gap causes real trouble. The gas meter has to connect to the hub on the electricity meter, and it can struggle if it is far away, or separated by thick walls or other environmental factors. Which? has heard from multiple owners whose electricity readings arrive fine while their gas readings never get through.
Flats, basements and rural homes are the most likely to suffer. If your meter is in a basement or a locked cupboard far from where you live, the signal may never have worked properly from day one. There are fixes. New 4G communications hubs can roam across multiple mobile networks, which helps where signal was limited. Virtual Wide Area Network connections offer an alternative for homes that cannot get a standard cellular or long-range radio connection. Ask your supplier about both if your meter has never communicated properly. And if your meter is hard to access, tell your supplier before installation so it can send the right equipment or ask you to clear the way. A meter nobody can reach is a meter nobody can fix.
Downside 9: some meters face a second replacement
Many older smart meters rely on 2G and 3G mobile networks, which the mobile operators are phasing out to free up bandwidth for 5G. The government and the operators have agreed that 2G and 3G will be switched off by 2033, and suppliers are now required to replace all smart meters still connected to those networks before the services end. That means a second visit, a second round of disruption, and for some households a second meter, for a device that was sold as a fit-and-forget upgrade. The scale is already visible in the official figures. In the second quarter of 2026, more than half of all smart meter installations by large suppliers were replacements of existing smart meters, not first-time fits. The replacement programme is free to you, and suppliers must take all reasonable steps to complete it before the switch-off, but it is still a visit you did not expect when the first meter went in.
The same logic applies to the SMETS1 meters that cannot be migrated to the national network. Those need a physical replacement too. If your supplier contacts you about an upgrade, it is worth asking whether the new meter is a current SMETS2 model on the national network, and whether the communications hub is 4G capable, so you are not back in the same position in a few years. A replacement is also an opportunity. If the original installation was done badly, with the meter in a poor location or the display never working, say so before the engineer arrives, and ask for the problems to be fixed as part of the visit.
Downside 10: the installation itself
Installation is free, but it is not nothing. You need to be at home for the visit, the power will be off for a short time while the electricity meter is swapped, and the engineer needs clear access to both meters. If your meters are in an awkward spot, a small cupboard, a case outside, or very high up, your supplier may ask you to dismantle the cupboard or clear obstacles before the visit, or arrive with the appropriate equipment. If you have a medical device that depends on electricity, tell your supplier in advance so the visit can be planned around it. The visit also comes with a sales risk. Installers must give you energy efficiency advice as part of the visit, and they need your permission in advance if they want to talk to you about their own products. If you do not want a sales conversation, say so when you book.
There is one more installation trap worth knowing. If your old gas meter has to be replaced because it is unsafe, you may not be able to refuse a smart meter in its place. Citizens Advice says that if your supplier claims there is a safety risk, you can ask for evidence. And if you still have an old radio teleswitch meter, the kind used on some older Economy 7 setups, Ofgem says support for those meters has now ended, so you should contact your supplier about a replacement. In both cases the choice is narrower than the usual right to refuse.
You are paying for the rollout whether you have one or not
Installation is free at the point of use, but the programme is not free. The cost of the national rollout is recovered through energy bills, spread across all customers through network charges, whether or not you have a smart meter. That means a household that refuses a smart meter still pays towards the cost of everyone else’s. There is no published per-household figure that stays still for long, because the programme’s costs and the number of households keep changing, but the principle matters for the decision. Refusing a smart meter does not save you the cost of the programme. It only means you do not get the benefits, accurate bills and access to off-peak tariffs, while still paying towards it. That does not make refusal wrong. It makes it a decision about the downsides on this list, not about money.
What to do if your smart meter goes wrong
If your smart meter stops sending readings, shows the wrong figures, or your display goes blank, start with your supplier, because it is responsible for making sure your meter works properly. Check your latest statement or your supplier’s app first, to see whether your readings are marked as smart or estimated. Then report the fault in writing so you have a record of the date. Since 23 February 2026, Ofgem’s Guaranteed Standards give you a timetable. Your supplier must tell you how it plans to resolve the problem within five working days. If it does not, it owes you 40 pounds in compensation, automatically. And since March 2026, suppliers must take all reasonable steps to fix a faulty smart meter as soon as possible and within 90 days of being notified, or face enforcement action from Ofgem, including fines. The 90-day rule does not cover a broken in-home display on its own, but the five-day plan rule does cover reported problems with the meter’s operation.
If your supplier misses the five-day deadline, tell it you believe you are owed the 40 pounds. If the meter still is not fixed after 90 days, ask for a date and a written explanation, and keep a record of every contact. If the complaint is not resolved after eight weeks, you can take it to the Energy Ombudsman, which can order a fix or compensation. Citizens Advice also has an online checker that tells you whether your meter should be working in smart mode, which is useful evidence when your supplier insists the problem is at your end. The new rules are a genuine improvement on the years when a dumb meter could sit unfixed indefinitely while the supplier and the network provider blamed each other. They only help if you use them, so report the fault, note the date, and hold your supplier to the timetable.
Who should still get a smart meter, and who should wait
After all of that, a smart meter is still worth having for many households. If you are on a standard variable tariff and pay by Direct Debit, a working smart meter ends estimated bills and gives you the half-hourly readings that unlock the cheapest off-peak tariffs. If you have solar panels and want to be paid for what you export, you almost certainly need one. If you like seeing what your energy costs in real time and changing your habits because of it, the display earns its keep. The case is weakest if your home has poor signal, your meters are in a basement or far apart, or you have already had a bad experience with a first-generation meter that went dumb. In those cases, ask your supplier to check the signal before booking, and ask for a 4G communications hub if coverage is marginal.
There is also a middle option that many people do not know about. You can ask for a smart meter with the smart features switched off, so it works like an ordinary meter and does not send data to your supplier. And you can accept a smart meter and then limit the readings to daily or monthly. Neither option is offered unprompted, so you have to ask. If you are still unsure, there is no rush. You do not legally have to accept a smart meter, suppliers cannot penalise you for declining, and you can always change your mind later. What you should not do is accept one and then ignore it when it stops working. A smart meter that has gone dumb is worse than an old meter, because it promises accurate bills and then quietly delivers estimates. Check your statements, report faults promptly, and use the 2026 rules. That is how you get the benefits without paying for the downsides.
Frequently asked questions
What are the downsides of smart meters in the UK?
What are the downsides of smart meters in the UK? Around 3 million smart meters are stuck in traditional mode and do not send readings, the in-home display is the part most likely to break, and a smart meter does not save you money on its own. Other downsides include half-hourly data collection, remote switching to prepayment, friction with solar panels, signal problems in flats and basements, and a second round of replacements as 2G and 3G networks switch off by 2033. Since 2026, suppliers must provide a fault-resolution plan within five working days and fix faulty meters within 90 days.
Can I refuse a smart meter?
Yes. You do not legally have to accept a smart meter, and your supplier cannot penalise you for declining. You may find it harder to get some tariffs, because the cheapest off-peak deals usually need a smart meter to work. You can also ask for a smart meter with the smart features switched off, so it works like an ordinary meter and does not send data. The exception is when an old gas meter has to be replaced because it is unsafe, in which case you may not be able to refuse a smart one, though you can ask your supplier for evidence of the safety risk.
Will a smart meter save me money?
Not by itself. A smart meter measures your energy use, it does not reduce it. Citizens Advice says a smart meter will not automatically save you money, and you save only when you change something because of what it shows you. Where it can save you money is tariffs: many cheaper off-peak and time-of-use deals need a smart meter. Accurate bills also end the cycle of estimated bills and catch-up charges, which is a saving of a different kind.
Why has my smart meter stopped sending readings?
The most common reasons are loss of network coverage, software on the meter that needs updating, a switch to a supplier that has not yet connected to your meter, a first-generation SMETS1 meter that was never migrated to the national network, or the physical location of the meter. Gas meters are a common trouble spot, because they connect through the electricity meter’s communications hub and can struggle across thick walls or long distances. Check whether your readings are marked as smart or estimated on your statement, then report the fault to your supplier, which must give you a resolution plan within five working days and fix it within 90 days.
Can my supplier switch my smart meter to prepayment?
Yes, technically, a smart meter can be switched to prepayment mode remotely. But the rules are the same as for a traditional meter. Prepayment for debt collection should only be a last resort, your supplier must first check that prepayment is safe, practical and easy for you to access and that you are not in a vulnerable situation, and you should get at least seven working days’ notice. If you think you have been moved to prepayment unfairly, complain to your supplier, and after eight weeks you can take it to the Energy Ombudsman.
How much data does a smart meter collect?
A smart meter records how much gas and electricity you use and what tariff you are on. By default, electricity readings are sent every half hour and gas readings once a month. You can ask your supplier for daily or monthly readings instead. Only your supplier, or a third party you have explicitly permitted, can see how much energy you use and when. The meter holds no name, address or bank details, and the Data Communications Company transports readings securely without storing your consumption data.
What should I do if my smart meter is faulty?
Report it to your supplier in writing and note the date. Under Ofgem rules in force since February 2026, your supplier must tell you how it plans to resolve the problem within five working days, or it owes you 40 pounds in compensation. It must then fix the meter within 90 days of being notified. If your in-home display is less than 12 months old and faulty, your supplier should fix or replace it free. If the complaint is not resolved after eight weeks, you can take it to the Energy Ombudsman.
Sources
- Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, Smart meters in Great Britain, quarterly update June 2026, GOV.UK statistical bulletin: 42 million smart and advanced meters, 72 percent of all meters, 92 percent of smart meters in smart mode, 3,133,000 in traditional mode, 1.1 million installed in April to June 2026.
- Citizens Advice, Citizens Advice responds to the government’s latest smart meter statistics, August 2026: 3 million smart meters failing to deliver, 36 percent of owners regularly submitting manual readings, 1.2 million households without accurate bills, smart meter problems the most common reason for complaints in 2026.
- Which?, Smart meter problems and how to solve them, updated 24 August 2026: 31 percent of 813 members had a problem in the past 12 months, in-home display the most common fault, replacement typically 30 to 50 pounds after 12 months, prepayment and solar guidance, 2017 radiation study.
- Smart DCC, Upgrading Britain’s first-generation smart meters: SMETS1 migration to the national network, most eligible meters migrated.
- Ofgem Guaranteed Standards, February 2026, and Department for Energy Security and Net Zero smart meter rules, March 2026: 40 pounds automatic compensation, five working day resolution plan, 90 day repair deadline, 2G and 3G replacement before switch-off by 2033.